This Season's Pies

Whole pies by special order

Please special order whole pies 48 hours ahead of time. A very limited selection of whole pies are available in the shop daily, but they sell very quickly.

Sweet Pies

Bourbon Pecan

Peanut Butter

Dark Chocolate Cream

Toasted Coconut Cream

Triple Citrus

Lemon Chess

Whiskey Chocolate Chip

Apple Cinnamon Crumble

Apple Cider

Honey-Spiced Pear

Brown Butter Pumpkin

Sweet Potato

Chai Vanilla Cream

Butterscotch Toffee


Top Your Slice

Fresh Whipped Cream

Homemade Ice Cream

Savory Pot Pies

Chicken, Bacon, & Roasted Garlic

Mushroom, Leek, & Gruyere

Cottage Pie

Turkey, Apple, & Brie

Potato Camembert

Broccoli Pimiento Cheese


Only "Chicken, Bacon, & Roasted Garlic", and "Mushroom, Leek & Gruyere Cheese" are always available as a special order family-size pot pie.
Please call (434) 977-0443 about what other choices are available for order. Please allow 48 hours.

Breakfast Hand Pies

Sausage, Goat Cheese, Honey & Egg

Spinach, Feta, & Egg

Yukon Potato, Cheddar, & Egg

Portabella Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions & Egg

Gluten Free • Vegan

Each day we will have at least one of each in savory and sweet.
Please keep in mind that our gluten-free offerings are made in the same baking facility as all of our product — we bake these products on a different day and take care to separate ingredients, but please consume wisely.

You can’t have it all

Not every pie is available every day. If we don’t have your favorite, try something new. It’s bad could it be?

© 2015-2017 The Pie Chest